Home / Blog / Article


December 9 2010

Florida Shows California that Demography is Still Not Destiny

Vicki E. Alger

California Governor-elect Jerry Brown and incoming Superintendent of Public Instruction Tom Torlakson want to improve education in the Golden State. They should begin by asking why Florida, though demographically similar to California, continues to trounce the state in student achievement. According to a new study from the Pacific Research Institute, low-income and minority students continue to propel Florida's gains while California student performance lags near the bottom.

The latest fourth-grade NAEP reading results reveal how California's failure to reform its public schools is putting students at an alarming disadvantage. Experts note that through third grade children must learn to read, but beginning in fourth grade they must read to learn. If students cannot read at grade level by fourth grade, they will continue to struggle in school and be at greater risk for dropping out later on.

Florida began a comprehensive public-education reform effort in 1999 that combined accountability, transparency and parental choice with far-reaching reforms such as alternative teacher certification and financial incentives for school success. Florida pursued those reforms from the top down through state testing and from the bottom up through parental choice.

Florida's approach emphasized standards for schools, transparency for parents and immediate options for students most at risk. The reforms included children trapped in chronically failing schools, from low-income families, from the foster-care system and children with disabilities. In 1998, the year before the Florida reforms began, four NAEP scale-score points separated California and Florida, 202 and 206, respectively. Florida ranked 34th out of 40 states participating in the NAEP reading assessment, and California ranked 37th. After a decade of comprehensive reform, Florida fourth-graders rank among the country's highest performers. The reading performance of California fourth-graders remains stuck near the bottom.

From 1998 to 2009, Florida fourth-graders achieved gains equivalent to two full grade levels in reading ability, 20 NAEP scale-score points. In contrast, California fourth-graders gained eight points, not quite one full grade level. Despite this gain, California tied with one other state for the country's fourth-worst fourth-grade NAEP reading score.

With a 13-point advantage, Florida's Hispanic fourth graders are the equivalent of nearly one-and-a-half grade levels ahead of all California fourth-graders in reading, and they outperform all fourth-graders in 26 other states.

Florida continues to expand its stunning success with bipartisan support. California lags behind because the state has refused to adopt large-scale and commonsense reforms that would allow students to attend schools their parents - not bureaucrats or special interest groups - think are best. With similar reforms, the Golden State could be a leader in student achievement instead of a cellar dweller.

Independent Women’s Forum’s mission is to improve the lives of Americans by increasing the number of women who value free markets and personal liberty. Sister organization of Independent Women’s Voice.
Follow us