The President recently challenged Saudi Arabia to release more oil. The U.S. and international community should also pressure Saudi Arabia to improve their human rights record, in particular their treatment of women and migrant workers.
According to Human Rights Watch, Saudi Arabia employs approximately 8 million migrant workers. Foreign workers come to Saudi Arabia to earn money to send back to their families and to escape poverty themselves. To secure their residency, workers must obtain an invitation and sponsorship from local Saudi employers.
Unfortunately, this practice puts those workers at the mercy of their employers who can withhold their passport and other legal documentation and prevent them for leaving their jobs. Some workers are even denied their earnings and subject to harsh conditions unspecified in their contract.
Female domestic workers have particular challenges and are vulnerable to exploitation. Some are forced to live in complete isolation and forbidden to leave the home in which they work. In addition to being overworked and underpaid, female migrant workers also face the risk of enduring physical and sexual abuse at the hands of their employers. Even when abuse is reported by foreign workers, it is extremely rare for Saudi employers to be prosecuted.
For example, the BBC recently reported that a Saudi couple who was accused of brutally abusing their Indonesian maid had their charges dropped by Saudi judges. Initially the maid, Nour Miyati, was sentenced to 70 lashes for falsely accusing her employers of mistreatment. Finally, she was awarded $670 in damages, hardly commensurate with the atrocious cruelty she suffered during her employment.
Most recently, a shelter holding Yemeni migrants was allegedly set on fire by Saudi authorities. Despite serious injuries, they were taken into custody for interrogation for two days without food or medical attention.
These are just more unfortunate reminders to the international community that foreigners living in Saudi Arabia face discrimination and are unable to receive equal treatment before the legal system.
It's not just foreigners, of course, who fail to find justice in Saudi Arabia. Women are routinely punished for crimes committed against them. In 2006, a Saudi woman was gang raped and later sentenced to 200 lashes and 6 months in prison. This caused a worldwide uproar which later resulted in the "gracious" pardon of the victim by King Abdullah.
Western governments and international human rights institutions must place pressure on the Saudi government to be more responsive in addressing charges of misconduct against migrant workers, and women generally. Governments whose citizens are migrant workers should take measures to ensure Saudi employment sponsors do not mistreat their employees.





2 Comments
bill | May 29, 2008, 1:57pm | #
I quote Prof. German Munoz of Miami Dade college to respond to Ms. Karzai when she insists that Muslim countries are not practicing true Islam while there are gross injustices against females:
"Muslim scholars often divide the world in three regions. Dar-al-Islam is the House of Islam where the vast majority of the population has submitted to Allah, and the government imposes sharia law or Islamic law on the people. The property of the infidel belongs to the umma or Islamic community. Dar-al-Sulh is the House of Truce or Transition. Non-Muslims, mostly dhimmis, live with Muslims. There is no full application of sharia law. Immigration of Muslims into this region and emigration of non-Muslims out of the area, gradually will give Islam the upper hand. Dar-al-Harb is the House of War, where non-Muslims predominate and is characterized by conflict. Here Muslims are in war and war is deceit. (Sahih Bukhari vol. 4, bk 56, no 3030). Muslims can perform violent actions against the infidels. Many Muslims, particularly among the Shiites, apply the concept of taqiya, which means deception in the face of superior force. It is justified to hide one’s own true beliefs and motivations until the appropriate time.
Ms. Karzai-either you have been fooled-totally-or you are trying to fool us. Wake up and stop being a water carrier for Islam. 9/11-terrorism waged by practicing Muslims.
"I will instill
terror into the hearts of the unbelievers: smite ye above
their necks [ cut off their heads] and smite all their finger-tips
off them” (Sura 8:12);
ConcernedWoman | May 31, 2008, 6:34pm | #
Thank you SO much for this article. I'm continually agast at the harsh treatment of women in Saudi.
Seventy lashes? For crying out for help!
It makes my heart break!